Barfly

Barfly on 3rd Avenue in the Flatiron District serves as a versatile spot that combines the casual appeal of a neighborhood bar with a surprisingly substantial menu that stretches from brunch staples to hearty bar & grill fare. It’s a place where you can grab a strong Jameson shot alongside a well-poured Miller Lite or dig into their Barfly Burger and wings after a day at work or in the midst of a casual hangout.

The atmosphere balances between lively and laid-back, making it appealing for a variety of visitors. Regulars who come for the pool league and sports on TV find a welcoming space to unwind without it getting overwhelmingly loud. There’s a relaxed buzz with good music in the background, alongside attentive staff who clearly know their regulars, which helps the place feel familiar rather than just another sports bar.

Barfly is particularly well-suited to those looking for an unpretentious yet well-rounded spot to catch a game, enjoy a casual meal, or settle in for happy hour. Their cocktail selections — including Mexican Margaritas and strong ciders like Strongbow — add to the appeal for anyone wanting a drink that’s a step beyond the usual draft beer. On the food side, the menu ticks classic comfort boxes with some interesting options like Dal Makhani and meatloaf, alongside familiar crowd-pleasers like nachos, sandwiches, and salads. The brunch offerings, such as Eggs Benedict and crispy chicken sandwiches, add a mid-morning draw for locals seeking a satisfying start to their weekend.

Service here comes up frequently as a highlight, with staff known for being personable and consistent, which is a big part of why people return. Even during busy times, the team makes an effort to attend to guests’ needs without feeling rushed. The outdoor seating provides an additional spot during warmer months to enjoy a drink or quick bite, blending the bar’s indoor buzz with the city’s street rhythm.

This spot fits well into the neighborhood’s mix of casual dining and nightlife. It’s not designed as a formal dining destination or a high-end cocktail lounge but rather a place where locals can relax, enjoy good food and drinks, and connect with others, whether for a post-work wind down, a casual brunch, or an evening of pool and games.